Regional Culture

 

 

 

 

 

 



About the Methodologies of Writing History and Educating History


“The era of offensive nationalism is not yet over. But, I do believe, that this kind of nationalism will eventually perish. What has happened to the Russians, the Austrians, to the Germans, will eventually become the fate of all the remaining imperialists…”

Yusuf Akçura, 1919

“Of the European historians, well, if not all, but certainly the majority are writing history dedicated to prove theories serving certain causes. This may be conscious or under the influence of the subconscious. Those events, not fitting into their theories are forgotten or appear very faint, those which serve the purpose bloat and are puffed up…”

Yusuf Akçura, 1932

 

My grandfather, Yusuf Akçura Bey, or Akçuraoglu Yusuf Bey, died 18 years before my birth. He was a learned man. His life had been spent in the Kazan district of Russia, in the Steppes of Central Asia, in Ottoman Istanbul, in exile in North Africa, in Paris, Zurich and finally in the Young Republic’s capital, in Ankara. From his writings and from family lore, mainly passed on by my great uncle Prof. Mazhar Sevket Ipsiroglu, “Yusuf Dede” had spent his life in search of truth. In this context “truth” was the ensemble of events which could withstand any interrogation and could be distilled by scientific and positive evidences.


Atatürk and Yusuf Akçura with the delegates at the First Historic Conference

Very clearly Yusuf Dede could observe the attempts of Russian and Western Culture to dominate over the Turkish World. Thus, he was an outspoken and relentless critique of those of his compatriots, who would support these attempts – be it in ignorance or be it for petty personal interests.

My grandfather never hesitated about “The Turk”s spiritual values and their contribution to world culture. For him, the fall of the Ottoman Empire was a transient period in history and the Turkish peoples - by the leadership of “the learned” - would certainly regain their historical place. He kept pointing at facts like with the fall of Kazan to Ivan the Terrible “Barbary had occupied civilization” and that some Russian Czars were of Turkish descent.

Did Yusuf Akçura defend the Turkish Imperialism? Certainly no. “Yusuf Dede” was called by contemporates not “the defender of the nation” but “ the defender of nations”. At every occasion he would outspokenly criticize offensive nationalism. As put in a essay in 1919 his ideal was nationalism based on law and order, observing mutual rights, defensive and peace oriented.

What can I say more than expressing my deep gratitude to all those who are able to think that like?

Yusuf Dede was the first chairman of the Turkish Historic Society. The Turkish Historical Congress, organized by the Society, took place 2 July 1932 – 11 July 1932 in the Ankara House of People. My grandfather’s contribution was. “About the Methodologies of Writing History and Educating History”. In a remarkable clear and transparent Turkish, obviously nurtured by his profound knowledge of many Turkic languages and in the best of the “Türk Yurdu” tradition he did not keep back to heavily criticize his fellow historians.

In summary he expresses his views about the teaching of history in general and in the Young Turkish Republic, and how to remain with the truths of history and with the universal values of mankind.

Below you will find my grandfathers speech as starting on July 11, 1932 at about 9 AM.

The speech is on pages 577 – 607 of the conference proceedings. The copy in my possession has been dedicated on March 10, 1933 to my grandmother, to my mother and my late uncle Tugrul. My mother was 9 at that time and my uncle Tugrul must have been four. My grandfather must have seen the need for an explanation. So, the dedication reads “That some may read it, and some may enjoy the pictures”. In an attempt that some may look at them I have appended some pictures to this web-page.

With the exception of obvious missettings I have not attempted to correct the spelling of 1932. Footnotes are mine and are about a few words I had to look up.

Yusuf Civelekoglu



Gazi Mustafa Kemal Atatürk leaving the conference

 

About the Methodologies of Writing History and Educating History - Tarih yazmak ve tarih okutmak usullerine dair

last update: 19.11.2004
Homepage  
yachtWORKS-bodrum, All Rights Reserved, © Copyright 2002
i 90